Protocol Online logo
Top : Forum Archives: : Paper and Grant Writing, Publishing and Presentation

how to response this Query please? - (Jan/04/2009 )

recently i received the proof of my article, but there is a Query(Please provide significance of “a” and “b” cited in table 1. Thank you.).

dose the editor mean i should provide the "a" and “b” when it is necessary? or i should provide the P value to the editor?

thank you !!!!!

-jinhaitai2006-

I think the reviewer asked you to do a statistical analysis (t test?) to see if there is a significant difference between a and b.

-pcrman-

QUOTE (pcrman @ Jan 4 2009, 08:50 PM)
I think the reviewer asked you to do a statistical analysis (t test?) to see if there is a significant difference between a and b.

but i have done the test, should i provide those P values to him?

-jinhaitai2006-

Most definately! If you have already done the statistical analysis and have an appropriate P value, why wouldn't you supply this information? The only thing it can do is support and strengthen your data.

-rkay447-

QUOTE (rkay447 @ Jan 5 2009, 07:17 AM)
Most definately! If you have already done the statistical analysis and have an appropriate P value, why wouldn't you supply this information? The only thing it can do is support and strengthen your data.

yes sir i will do it

-jinhaitai2006-